Why don’t I recognize Earth?

I follow the astronaut Scott Kelly on twitter.  While he was in space he did this thing with earth pictures where he likened them to art without identifying the place in the picture. I could never figure out the place – although sometimes I think a cartographer would not have been able to.  Because he’d focused on a gorgeous pattern but it didn’t have an easy reference point.

image

But sometimes he challenged people to identify the place and it did have something you could reference if you knew something about geography.  I could NEVER identify it.

EVEN when he said what I was looking at, I was at a loss for several moments because it’s not oriented the way my schooling taught me the earth is oriented.

image

I think we do a big disservice to kids in constantly orienting maps with the north at the top.  It makes us internalize the idea that there is a top to earth.  AND THERE ISN’T.  No up.  No down.

North at the top is just a function of tradition.  Yeah, I know the magnetic pole thing – but honestly – in space its just a ball floating in a whole lot of vacuum.   And while the planets are on a sort of plane with the sun, AGAIN, is that really related to how the continents are on our sphere?

image

This is a Dymaxion map designed by Buckminster Fuller.  Its designed to give land masses their proper ratios.  Notice that Greenland is NOT the same size as Africa.  Of course this means none of the water is accurate.  Maps, man. Can’t be trusted.

Anyway, I guess I think that if you taught geography as a kind of wild puzzle, without orientation to the north, it would be far more captivating to kids.  If you showed them all the crazy ideas that cartographers have come up with to map the world that challenge their ideas of how the world is actually carved up – it might wake them up a bit.  They might actually learn where Malaysia is vs Madagascar

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Why don’t I recognize Earth?

  1. The Earth rotates on an axis and therefore North is always North and the top half of the planet..that never changes.. the south pole never is on top of the planet. What changed was Scott Kelly. From his position what looked to be the top wasn’t always North.
    Now having said that… I couldn’t identify anything on my flight from St. Louis to New York, so hoping to identify anything from space would be ridiculous for me. Still, I’ll bet his feed is really interesting.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s